This post contains affiliate links marked with (*). If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Part 4 of the series: All Harry Potter fan theories

To most fans, Rubeus Hagrid is the lovable gamekeeperGamekeeper Hagrid's job: Keeper of Keys and Grounds at Hogwarts. with a huge heart and a soft spot for dangerous creatures. A powerful wizard? Not so much. One fan theory sees it very differently: if Hagrid had been allowed to finish his education, he might have become one of the strongest wizards of his time – and that’s exactly what Tom Riddle wanted to prevent. Let’s look at what the books say in favor of the theory, what speaks against it – and how much truth is in it.
Why Was Hagrid Expelled From Hogwarts?
Hagrid is the son of a wizard and the giantess Fridwulfa – a half-giantHalf-giant Hagrid is a half-giant: the son of a wizard and a giantess. Giants live in clans.. In his third year, he was expelled from HogwartsHogwarts Hogwarts is the British school of witchcraft and wizardry in the Scottish Highlands. Young witches and wizards study magic there for seven years from the age of eleven, sorted into four houses: Gryffindor, Hufflepuff, Ravenclaw and Slytherin.More about Hogwarts → and his wandWand A witch's or wizard's most important tool for casting spells; as Ollivander says, the wand chooses the wizard. was snapped. The reason: he was accused of opening the Chamber of SecretsChamber of Secrets Secret chamber beneath Hogwarts built by Salazar Slytherin., which led to a student’s death.
In reality, it was Tom Riddle, the future Voldemort. As we learn in Chamber of Secrets, Riddle pinned the blame on Hagrid and the giant spider Aragog he was secretly raising. Riddle even received an award for it. Only Dumbledore believed Hagrid was innocent and made sure he could stay on at Hogwarts as gamekeeper.
The Fan Theory: Hagrid Could Have Been a Powerful Wizard

The theory comes from a Reddit post on r/harrypotter. Here’s the core idea:
Hagrid had what it takes to become an exceptionally powerful wizard. His giant blood, his bond with magical creatures and his raw talent would have made him a serious threat to dark wizards – if he’d been fully trained. Tom Riddle recognized this early and deliberately took Hagrid out before he could reach his potential.
The Evidence for the Theory
He Does Magic With a Broken Wand
Hagrid’s wand was snapped when he was expelled. Yet he keeps doing magic – with a pink umbrella that apparently hides the pieces of his old wand. In Sorcerer’s Stone, he uses it to light a fire in the hut on the rock and to give Dudley a pig’s tail. Partially transfiguring a human with a broken wand and just three years of training is anything but weak.
Spells Bounce Right Off Him
In Order of the PhoenixOrder of the Phoenix Secret society founded by Dumbledore to fight Voldemort., several Ministry officials try to arrest Hagrid at night. They fire Stunning Spells at him – and Hagrid stays on his feet. A single one of those spells is normally enough to knock out a person. Professor McGonagall is hit by several Stunners in the same scene and ends up in St Mungo’s. Hagrid fights back and escapes.
He’s a Diplomat Between Worlds
In Order of the Phoenix, Dumbledore sends Hagrid and Madame Maxime to the giants to win them over to the Order. The fact that Dumbledore picks him for this mission shows that Hagrid’s heritage and his way with beings others fear are a real strength.
Nobody Understands Magical Creatures Like He Does
Dragons, hippogriffs, thestrals, a giant spider and a three-headed dog: Hagrid tames creatures that trained wizards would run from. Starting with Prisoner of AzkabanAzkaban The wizarding prison on an island, guarded by Dementors., he even teaches Care of Magical Creatures.
Tom Riddle Had a Reason
Riddle could have blamed anyone. He chose Hagrid. The obvious explanation: Hagrid really was keeping a dangerous creature in the castle, which made him the perfect scapegoat. The theory goes further: maybe Riddle also saw the young half-giant as a potential rival he’d rather get rid of early.
What Speaks Against the Theory
His Spells Often Go Wrong
The pig’s tail cuts both ways. Hagrid actually meant to turn Dudley into a pig. The fact that he only managed a tail suggests a lack of control rather than hidden power. In general, Hagrid is better known for botched magic and dangerous pets than for precise spellwork.
Resilience Isn’t the Same as Magical Power
Stunning Spells bounce off Hagrid because of his giant blood – according to the books, giants are highly resistant to magic. That makes him tough, but not automatically a powerful wizard. A troll isn’t easily impressed either.
The Mission to the Giants Fails
Hagrid and Madame Maxime don’t win the giants over to the Order. In the end, some of them even side with Voldemort. So Hagrid’s diplomatic skills have their limits.
Riddle Just Needed a Scapegoat
There’s a simple explanation for Riddle’s choice: Hagrid was secretly keeping Aragog in the castle. Riddle needed someone he could believably pin the attacks on – not necessarily a dangerous rival.
Dumbledore Doesn’t Fear Hagrid – He Trusts Him
One version of the theory claims Dumbledore kept Hagrid at Hogwarts to keep him under control. The books show the opposite: in the very first chapter of Sorcerer’s Stone, Dumbledore says he would trust Hagrid with his life – and sends him to bring baby Harry from Godric’s Hollow.
How Powerful Is Hagrid, Really? My Take

Meine Einschätzung
I don’t think Hagrid could have become the most powerful wizard of his time – too many of his spells go sideways for that. But the theory gets one important thing right: Hagrid is massively underrated. He does magic with a broken wand, shrugs off Stunning Spells and travels to the giants on Dumbledore’s behalf. My version of the theory: Hagrid’s real potential was never in spells, but in building bridges – to creatures, to giants and to a little boy getting his very first birthday cake.
What do you think? Underrated wizard, or simply the best gamekeeper Hogwarts ever had? Let me know in the comments!
More theories:
Final Thoughts
Whether Hagrid would have become a great wizard without Tom Riddle’s scheme will always remain an open question. But the theory shows how much there is to a character many people see only as a gentle giant. It’ll be exciting to see how the new HBO series portrays him: Nick Frost plays Hagrid, and season one, Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s StonePhilosopher’s Stone Nicolas Flamel's alchemical stone, which produces the Elixir of Life., premieres on Christmas Day 2026.
Want to revisit Hagrid’s story in the original? The Harry Potter books are available as a paperback box set (*), and the movies as a Blu-ray collection (*).
Hagrid FAQ
Images: © Warner Bros.
This post contains affiliate links marked with (*). If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.




